Difference between revisions of "Talk:Caning"

Active discussions
(re)
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
The top picture, "The governess", seems to me not ideal. The method shown is not how caning was done, and actually is not at all an effective way of doing it. A much more typical caning scene would show an older boy bending over, with a schoolmaster holding the cane standing behind and to one side. -- [[User:Pineapple|Pineapple]] ([[User talk:Pineapple|talk]]) 08:11, 6 December 2012 (UTC)
 
The top picture, "The governess", seems to me not ideal. The method shown is not how caning was done, and actually is not at all an effective way of doing it. A much more typical caning scene would show an older boy bending over, with a schoolmaster holding the cane standing behind and to one side. -- [[User:Pineapple|Pineapple]] ([[User talk:Pineapple|talk]]) 08:11, 6 December 2012 (UTC)
   
:Typical for British style school canings (including the Commonwealth), yes. School canings in other cultures may differ (e.g. Germany seems to have favored [[bent-over-object position]]s in school cp). Rogue added a drawing by Dave Ell of a British style classroom caning. If you know a better example, feel free to add or replace it. --[[User:Spankart|Spankart]] ([[User talk:Spankart|talk]]) 18:48, 6 December 2012 (UTC)
+
:I agree the "governess" picture is not "typical", and what you said is indeed typical for British style school canings (including the Commonwealth). School canings in other cultures may differ (e.g. Germany seems to have favored [[bent-over-object position]]s in school cp). Rogue added a drawing by Dave Ell of a British style classroom caning. If you know a better example, feel free to add or replace it. --[[User:Spankart|Spankart]] ([[User talk:Spankart|talk]]) 18:48, 6 December 2012 (UTC)
  +
::"Bent over object" is fine (and incidentally, equally typical for England). It is caning over the knee or in the lap that is not practical in reality because there is not room enough to get the necessary swing at the target area. The Dave Ell drawing is much better. -- [[User:Pineapple|Pineapple]] ([[User talk:Pineapple|talk]]) 08:22, 7 December 2012 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 08:22, 7 December 2012

Appropriateness of pictureEdit

The top picture, "The governess", seems to me not ideal. The method shown is not how caning was done, and actually is not at all an effective way of doing it. A much more typical caning scene would show an older boy bending over, with a schoolmaster holding the cane standing behind and to one side. -- Pineapple (talk) 08:11, 6 December 2012 (UTC)

I agree the "governess" picture is not "typical", and what you said is indeed typical for British style school canings (including the Commonwealth). School canings in other cultures may differ (e.g. Germany seems to have favored bent-over-object positions in school cp). Rogue added a drawing by Dave Ell of a British style classroom caning. If you know a better example, feel free to add or replace it. --Spankart (talk) 18:48, 6 December 2012 (UTC)
"Bent over object" is fine (and incidentally, equally typical for England). It is caning over the knee or in the lap that is not practical in reality because there is not room enough to get the necessary swing at the target area. The Dave Ell drawing is much better. -- Pineapple (talk) 08:22, 7 December 2012 (UTC)
Return to "Caning" page.